I've merged these two threads about the same subject.As for what I'll do, for now we're still mid season, so I'm scraping out the failing (gunky) caulking as and when it occurs, although I've ran out of solvents to clean up the sticky stuff tread around all over the boat and it's very annoying. Last few small supermarkets here in Greece didn't have the handy cleaning alcohol that was widely available all over Italy.
Ours doesn't seem to have plywood backing, it's teak directly glued on top of the non-skid. There may be just enough teak left to recaulk it all and sand it down for a few more years of delaying the inevitable, but it's a lot of work and I'm not keen on doing the job twice.
So I'd rather remove it all and apply something more practical instead. That probably means either non-skid paint or
TBS sheets (I don't like the treadmaster pattern). Other alternatives are either too expensive or too offensive. Too expensive includes cork, which looks like a good solution if you're willing to spend a lot. Too offensive includes real teak or fake-stripey PVC decking, as I really don't see the point of it and the fake teak look and pointless caulking stripes offend me
The removing doesn't look that horrible, I'll probably go through a few oscillating multi-tools though and have to take breaks for my rubbish knees. Seen someone do it a few years ago on a similar sized boat. The major work will be in then preparing the deck underneath, i.e. cleaning, fixing holes, fairing and applying whatever product it will be afterwards. Needs some good weather window too!
I don't think the original non-skid pattern can be freed from the adhesives and it also looks like it was damaged in areas during the installation, or perhaps before and never fixed as the boat was going to be covered in teak anyways, so it didn't matter.
Although maybe you want to try our laundry detergent that seems to have the ability to dissolve caulking