I have always used the alternative, except when i had the work undertaken by two yards, and they did not do it. I noticed some corrosion, and have gone back to my original strategy, and believe it is the safest option for little effort. Also worth remembering that corrosion rates from any differential will vary with location, salinity, water contamination or temperature and stray marina currents, so i suppose it comes back to personal assessment of risk.
Have fun scrubbing !